Tom Takes Becky’s Whipping

Tom Takes Becky’s Whipping

Before you begin

Before you begin, know that this one starts as a spat and ends somewhere neither child expected. A boy tries to make up with a girl, gets his head bitten off for it, and spends the next hour deciding he will enjoy watching her get what she deserves. For most of the scene he is not a hero. He is a boy nursing a grudge.

Then watch what the grudge is worth when the moment comes. Becky is cornered, a single question away from a whipping she has never once taken, and Tom has the whole thing in his hands. What he does with it happens faster than thought, before the scheming part of him can object.

And watch the price. He takes a real punishment for a thing he did not do, in front of the whole school, and says nothing. The reward is one look from across the room, and the scene is sure that it was worth it.

Read the illustrated retelling on Kindle →
Tom on his feet confessing, from the illustrated retelling
From the illustrated graphic novel.

Tom Takes Becky’s Whipping

As Mark Twain wrote it, 1876 · The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, Chapter XX

THERE was something about Aunt Polly’s manner, when she kissed Tom, that swept away his low spirits and made him light-hearted and happy again. He started to school and had the luck of coming upon Becky Thatcher at the head of Meadow Lane. His mood always determined his manner. Without a moment’s hesitation he ran to her and said:

“I acted mighty mean to-day, Becky, and I’m so sorry. I won’t ever, ever do that way again, as long as ever I live — please make up, won’t you?”

The girl stopped and looked him scornfully in the face:

“I’ll thank you to keep yourself to yourself, Mr. Thomas Sawyer. I’ll never speak to you again.”

She tossed her head and passed on. Tom was so stunned that he had not even presence of mind enough to say “Who cares, Miss Smarty?” until the right time to say it had gone by. So he said nothing. But he was in a fine rage, nevertheless. He moped into the schoolyard wishing she were a boy, and imagining how he would trounce her if she were. He presently encountered her and delivered a stinging remark as he passed. She hurled one in return, and the angry breach was complete. It seemed to Becky, in her hot resentment, that she could hardly wait for school to “take in,” she was so impatient to see Tom flogged for the injured spelling-book. If she had had any lingering notion of exposing Alfred Temple, Tom’s offensive fling had driven it entirely away.

Poor girl, she did not know how fast she was nearing trouble herself. The master, Mr. Dobbins, had reached middle age with an unsatisfied ambition. The darling of his desires was, to be a doctor, but poverty had decreed that he should be nothing higher than a village schoolmaster. Every day he took a mysterious book out of his desk and absorbed himself in it at times when no classes were reciting. He kept that book under lock and key. There was not an urchin in school but was perishing to have a glimpse of it, but the chance never came. Every boy and girl had a theory about the nature of that book; but no two theories were alike, and there was no way of getting at the facts in the case. Now, as Becky was passing by the desk, which stood near the door, she noticed that the key was in the lock! It was a precious moment. She glanced around; found herself alone, and the next instant she had the book in her hands. The title-page — Professor Somebody’s Anatomy — carried no information to her mind; so she began to turn the leaves. She came at once upon a handsomely engraved and colored frontispiece — a human figure, stark naked. At that moment a shadow fell on the page and Tom Sawyer stepped in at the door and caught a glimpse of the picture. Becky snatched at the book to close it, and had the hard luck to tear the pictured page half down the middle. She thrust the volume into the desk, turned the key, and burst out crying with shame and vexation.

“Tom Sawyer, you are just as mean as you can be, to sneak up on a person and look at what they’re looking at.”

“How could I know you was looking at anything?”

“You ought to be ashamed of yourself, Tom Sawyer; you know you’re going to tell on me, and oh, what shall I do, what shall I do! I’ll be whipped, and I never was whipped in school.”

Then she stamped her little foot and said:

“Be so mean if you want to! I know something that’s going to happen. You just wait and you’ll see! Hateful, hateful, hateful!” — and she flung out of the house with a new explosion of crying.

Tom stood still, rather flustered by this onslaught. Presently he said to himself:

“What a curious kind of a fool a girl is! Never been licked in school! Shucks! What’s a licking! That’s just like a girl — they’re so thin-skinned and chicken-hearted. Well, of course I ain’t going to tell old Dobbins on this little fool, because there’s other ways of getting even on her, that ain’t so mean; but what of it? Old Dobbins will ask who it was tore his book. Nobody’ll answer. Then he’ll do just the way he always does — ask first one and then t’other, and when he comes to the right girl he’ll know it, without any telling. Girls’ faces always tell on them. They ain’t got any backbone. She’ll get licked. Well, it’s a kind of a tight place for Becky Thatcher, because there ain’t any way out of it.” Tom conned the thing a moment longer, and then added: “All right, though; she’d like to see me in just such a fix — let her sweat it out!”

Tom joined the mob of skylarking scholars outside. In a few moments the master arrived and school “took in.” Tom did not feel a strong interest in his studies. Every time he stole a glance at the girls’ side of the room Becky’s face troubled him. Considering all things, he did not want to pity her, and yet it was all he could do to help it. He could get up no exultation that was really worthy the name. Presently the spelling-book discovery was made, and Tom’s mind was entirely full of his own matters for a while after that. Becky roused up from her lethargy of distress and showed good interest in the proceedings. She did not expect that Tom could get out of his trouble by denying that he spilt the ink on the book himself; and she was right. The denial only seemed to make the thing worse for Tom. Becky supposed she would be glad of that, and she tried to believe she was glad of it, but she found she was not certain. When the worst came to the worst, she had an impulse to get up and tell on Alfred Temple, but she made an effort and forced herself to keep still — because, said she to herself, “he’ll tell about me tearing the picture sure. I wouldn’t say a word, not to save his life!”

Tom took his whipping and went back to his seat not at all broken-hearted, for he thought it was possible that he had unknowingly upset the ink on the spelling-book himself, in some skylarking bout — he had denied it for form’s sake and because it was custom, and had stuck to the denial from principle.

A whole hour drifted by, the master sat nodding in his throne, the air was drowsy with the hum of study. By and by, Mr. Dobbins straightened himself up, yawned, then unlocked his desk, and reached for his book, but seemed undecided whether to take it out or leave it. Most of the pupils glanced up languidly, but there were two among them that watched his movements with intent eyes. Mr. Dobbins fingered his book absently for a while, then took it out and settled himself in his chair to read! Tom shot a glance at Becky. He had seen a hunted and helpless rabbit look as she did, with a gun levelled at its head. Instantly he forgot his quarrel with her. Quick — something must be done! done in a flash, too! But the very imminence of the emergency paralyzed his invention. Good! — he had an inspiration! He would run and snatch the book, spring through the door and fly. But his resolution shook for one little instant, and the chance was lost — the master opened the volume. If Tom only had the wasted opportunity back again! Too late. There was no help for Becky now, he said. The next moment the master faced the school. Every eye sank under his gaze. There was that in it which smote even the innocent with fear. There was silence while one might count ten — the master was gathering his wrath. Then he spoke: “Who tore this book?”

There was not a sound. One could have heard a pin drop. The stillness continued; the master searched face after face for signs of guilt.

“Benjamin Rogers, did you tear this book?”

A denial. Another pause.

“Joseph Harper, did you?”

Another denial. Tom’s uneasiness grew more and more intense under the slow torture of these proceedings. The master scanned the ranks of boys — considered a while, then turned to the girls:

“Amy Lawrence?”

A shake of the head.

“Gracie Miller?”

The same sign.

“Susan Harper, did you do this?”

Another negative. The next girl was Becky Thatcher. Tom was trembling from head to foot with excitement and a sense of the hopelessness of the situation.

“Rebecca Thatcher” [Tom glanced at her face — it was white with terror] — “did you tear — no, look me in the face” [her hands rose in appeal] — “did you tear this book?”

A thought shot like lightning through Tom’s brain. He sprang to his feet and shouted — “I done it!”

The school stared in perplexity at this incredible folly. Tom stood a moment, to gather his dismembered faculties; and when he stepped forward to go to his punishment the surprise, the gratitude, the adoration that shone upon him out of poor Becky’s eyes seemed pay enough for a hundred floggings. Inspired by the splendor of his own act, he took without an outcry the most merciless flaying that even Mr. Dobbins had ever administered; and also received with indifference the added cruelty of a command to remain two hours after school should be dismissed — for he knew who would wait for him outside till his captivity was done, and not count the tedious time as loss, either.

Tom went to bed that night planning vengeance against Alfred Temple; for with shame and repentance Becky had told him all, not forgetting her own treachery; but even the longing for vengeance had to give way, soon, to pleasanter musings, and he fell asleep at last with Becky’s latest words lingering dreamily in his ear —

“Tom, how could you be so noble!”


Tom Takes Becky’s Whipping, Told Once More

A modern retelling by R. M. Hume

Tom walked to school that morning feeling fine, and the first good thing in his path was Becky Thatcher. He ran straight up to her. He was sorry, he said, truly sorry, he’d been mean and he’d never be mean again as long as he lived, and please would she make up.

Becky stopped and looked him coldly in the face. She would thank him to keep himself to himself, Mr. Thomas Sawyer, and she would never speak to him again. Then she tossed her head and walked on.

By the time Tom thought of a crushing thing to say back, the moment for saying it was long gone, so he said nothing and simmered instead. The two of them traded a few stinging remarks across the schoolyard, and the quarrel sealed itself shut. Becky was so angry she could hardly wait for class to start, because Tom was in trouble over a ruined spelling-book, and she wanted to watch him get whipped for it. She happened to know he was innocent. That only made her want to watch more.

What she did not know was how close her own turn was.

The schoolmaster, Mr. Dobbins, had wanted to be a doctor. Instead, he was teaching at the village school. He kept a mysterious book locked in his desk, and every day he would take it out and read it when no one was reciting, and then lock it away again. Every child in that school was dying to know what it was. Nobody ever got the chance. So when Becky passed the desk and saw the key sitting right there in the lock, with no one around, she could not help herself. She lifted the book out and opened it.

It was an anatomy book. She had just turned to a picture of the human body when a shadow crossed the page. Tom was standing in the doorway, looking right at it. Becky grabbed to shut the book and tore the page half down the middle instead. She shoved it back in the desk, turned the key, and burst into tears, ashamed and frightened.

She rounded on him. He was mean, she said, sneaking up to see what a person was looking at. He hadn’t the faintest idea she’d been looking at anything, Tom said, but she was past hearing him. He’d tell on her, she knew he would, and she’d be whipped, and she had never once been whipped in school. She stamped her foot, told him to go ahead and be as mean as he liked, promised he would get what was coming to him, and flew out of the room crying harder than before.

Tom stood there a little rattled, and then he reasoned it out the way boys do. A girl couldn’t take a licking, that was plain. And there was no hiding it either. Dobbins would hold up the torn book and go down the rows asking one child after another, and when he reached the guilty face he would know it, because girls’ faces always gave them away. She would be caught no matter what Tom said or didn’t say. So that was that. She’d have been glad enough to see him in a tight spot. Let her sweat it out.

Class took in. Soon enough the spelling-book business came up, and Tom was called out for it. He hadn’t done it, but he denied it the way you deny things on principle, which somehow made it look worse, and he took his whipping and sat back down not much bothered. Across the room, Becky could have cleared him with one word about who really spoiled the book. She kept the word behind her teeth. If she spoke up, Tom would surely tell about the torn page, and she would not give him that, not to save his life.

Then an hour of drowsy quiet, and Dobbins reached for his book. Tom glanced at Becky. She looked terrified, and every bit of the quarrel went straight out of his head. He had one wild second to think of snatching the book and bolting. He hesitated, and the second passed, and the master opened the cover and saw the ruin.

Dobbins turned on the whole school, and the room went so still you could have heard a pin land. Who tore this book? No one breathed. He started down the rows, one name at a time. Benjamin Rogers, did you? A denial. Joseph Harper? Another. Closer and closer he came, and when he had worked through the boys he turned and started along the girls too, until the next one in line was Becky Thatcher, white to the lips. Rebecca Thatcher, the master said, did you tear this book? Look me in the face. Did you tear this book?

Tom was on his feet before he knew it.

“I did it.”

The whole school turned to stare at him like he’d lost his mind. He walked up to take his punishment, and the look that came back at him out of Becky’s eyes, the gratitude and the plain adoration of it, was worth a hundred floggings. He took the worst whipping Dobbins had in him without a sound, and heard the extra sentence of two hours after school without flinching, because he knew exactly who would be waiting outside for him the whole time, and would not count a minute of it wasted.

That night Becky told him everything, the torn page and the ruined spelling-book both, her own little betrayal and all. Tom went to bed planning revenge on the boy who had let him take the blame for the ink. But even that faded off into something softer, and the last thing in his ears as he fell asleep was Becky saying it over again.

“Tom, how could you be so noble!”


What Twain Was Doing

Twain published this in 1876, in the twentieth chapter of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. The scene is built on a reversal he sets up in plain sight. Tom and Becky are at war, and Twain lets Tom plan his small revenge out loud, the way a boy does, reasoning that a girl cannot hide a guilty face and will be caught no matter what he says. The reader is told exactly how little nobility is in him.

That is the setup for the turn. When the master works down the rows and reaches Becky, white to the lips, Twain gives Tom no moment of visible decision. The boy is on his feet before he knows it himself. The whole weight of the scene rides on that speed. Had Tom paused to be brave, it would be a lesson. Because he does not pause, it is character, the real thing showing up underneath the grudge before the grudge can stop it.

Then Twain pays it off quietly. Tom takes the worst whipping the master has, and the extra sentence on top of it, without a sound, and the only wages he draws are the look in Becky’s eyes and, that night, her last words going over in his ear. Twain lets a boy be petty and gallant in the same half hour and does not reconcile the two, because he knows they do not need reconciling.


A Note on This Edition

Twain’s text is reproduced verbatim from the 1876 publication, with two small typographic normalizations to match the rest of this series: the original double hyphens are set as em dashes, and the few words Twain emphasized in capitals are set in italics instead. Nothing has been rewritten or modernized. The only additions within the passage are the annotations, which explain words, references, and historical context without changing the underlying text. The retelling below is the only rewritten version. The retelling and these notes were written by R. M. Hume with the help of AI.

This scene is the whole of the twentieth chapter of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer: the snubbed makeup on Meadow Lane, the master’s locked anatomy book and the key left in the lock, the torn page, Tom’s cold reasoning, the roll-call down the rows, “I done it,” the whipping taken in silence, and the quiet of that night.

This is one of the Tom Sawyer pieces in Mark Twain in an AI World, alongside Whitewashing the Fence, The Pinchbug and the Poodle, The Pain-Killer and the Cat, The Sunday-School Prize, Examination Evening, The Tick in School, and Tom and Becky’s First Courtship. As in the rest of the series, Twain’s own text sits word for word beside a plain modern retelling, so you can see exactly what was changed and what was not.

More on Twain’s method:
How Twain Said to Tell It →
 · 
The Rulebook Twain Hid in an Insult →